But, all and still, I think this was a good battle. The song was good. The variation was good. Participation was good. Comments were good. It was all good. The voting wasn't as close as I like, but you don't get everything you want!
In the end, the tally looked like this for You Angel You:
Bob Dylan: 17 votes (including mine)
Manfred Mann: 7
I realize I haven't done a soundtrack post in a while. I also realize I'm going to be packing up (literally this time) and leaving for camp soon. Last time I posted I was in NYC, but really close to packing that up in order to move to Savannah, Georgia, when J1 would be relocated to Fort Stewart, Georgia. That was 1992.
I realize now that I think about this entire time as a block of time (1992-1995)... the time when J1 and I lived together. So many things happened, but most of them were small things. Point of fact: I didn't understand most of what happened in this relationship until years and years and years after it ended. And I wonder, even as I try and consolidate it now if I my take on it will change at some point in the future? I know that I thought the reasons for it ending were different ten years ago than I think today, so who knows what I will think ten years from now? And isn't it odd that I can't think about the reality of the relationship without the ending of the relationship? I think that may be because I see now that it was always hanging by a thread or starving or one breath away from dying all along. I don't know. That doesn't mean we weren't happy. We were. Sometimes very much. But so are people who live paycheck to paycheck and don't know that the boss is discussing eliminating their position.
- We really liked doing many of the same things. We had fun together.
- J1 was a terrible communicator when he was upset about something. So, when he did let it out, it was like a volcano erupting. It was the current thing, plus the thing from last week, last month, and maybe even something from last year that you did that really pissed him off. All at once. With no opportunity to respond to any of them.
- J1 was a helpful person. He liked to help. He was good about helping in the kitchen cooking or wherever help was needed.
- J1 was downright scary when he lost his temper. It didn't happen often, but people who lost control are frightening. He scared me sometimes. He never hurt me, but he scared me several times. I think he scared himself sometimes.
- In the move to Georgia, I really lost myself in terms of my "career." There is no publishing in Savannah. I didn't know what to do with myself. It didn't get better when we moved back to Michigan. He went back to school, but I was still feeling aimless. I got a job as a secretary, but it felt like a waste of my education. And I probably blamed J1 for my choice to leave NYC, which wasn't good for our relationship (or fair to boot, since it was my choice).
And this might sound a bit crazy... more so if you've never lived anything like it, but I loved him at the end, and I didn't anymore. I loved him in the way a person always loves their first love. But I didn't love him in the way that I should've stopped loving him as soon as he told me that he didn't contact me after getting all of my letters because "he didn't want to hurt me anymore." It was like that statement finally caught up to me (even though I didn't yet know that was what caught up to me). My soul recognized that he didn't love me enough, even if he didn't know it yet. Not enough to get married.
Of course, at the time I didn't know any of that stuff. I just knew it wasn't working, and I didn't get it.
I never thought I could feel this way and I've got to say that I just don't get it
I don't know where we went wrong, but the feeling's gone and I just can't get it back
I like Gordon Lightfoot and that song too. Relationships need a lot of work and understanding on both sides. As you get more distant from the real event, you can look at it more objectively. Sometimes the hurt and misunderstanding take a lot longer to get over.
ReplyDeleteGreat song which really goes with what you wrote here. The Hurt's and anger and resentments can be so strong and, with time, thankfully, dissipate. The BOTB may have been lopsided but I still enjoy it and like the unexpected or expected.... It always works no matter what the outcome
ReplyDeleteI have come to appreciate Lightfoot more than I did back in his heydey. Yeah, relationships are hard.
ReplyDeleteCommunication is hard. I find I do not bring up negative things for fear of hurting someone's feelings, and then when it finally comes out (and it always does), it's a big deal. I used to be an eruptor, somewhere in my forties I learned to (mostly) control that part of me.
For what it's worth, I am almost 55 and I still don't get it when it does not work out.
Maybe it's just like my girl Patty says....
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yX9aASk3Df0
Sometimes relationships take hard work but when it's so much work day in and day out to the point of being absolutely exhausting and you don't see any kind of improvement or benefits, it's time to let go. I'm glad you saw that. I'm glad you recognized the toxic around you.
ReplyDeleteI know a few people with tempers like that, it's definitely scary.
ReplyDeleteLove Gordon Lightfoot! Great song.
ReplyDeleteIt sucks when two people get together and seem so good together at first, but then it all falls apart. Been there. More than once... :)
Being scared of your partner is never a good thing...
Surprising results on your BOTB! I'm shocked that so many voted for Bob Dylan! I still like Manford Mann's version...
Have a good weekend Robin!
Michele at Angels Bark
Gordon Lightfoot was the perfect accompaniment to your heartbreaking story! At least you realized the relationship wasn't working before you got married.
ReplyDeleteI voted for Bob and don't usually like his voice, so that's something.
Have a good weekend.
There is a big difference between loving someone and being in love with someone. You were wise not to force things.
ReplyDeleteYour Battle wasn't all that bad. It kind of went the same way that mine did, but then I started thinking about other things besides my BOTB post. These things are supposed to be fun and that's where I try to be with it.
ReplyDeleteA relationship doesn't work when mind reading is involved. Unfortunately it happens a lot. I guess it's kind of human nature or something.
Arlee Bird
Tossing It Out
I can understand why the BOTB total would 'bum' you out, but like Arlee I say, "keep it fun"...at least for yourself!
ReplyDeleteGordon Lightfoot's song impacted my life also. I had one of those, 'where did it go' epiphanies, 20 years after my exit. funny how life happens like that... just like that.
Perfect son for the story you describe...sometimes though, we just have to let the story go...
ReplyDeleteIve missed your soundtrack posts! Dang now is that a song that fits perfectly with your story or what?! Oh Gordon Lightfoot- so great. Still alive and living in Canada I think. I will totally write you again in camp and like you, cant make any promises you can read my penmanship.
ReplyDelete